Taxation of Shareholder Loans: A Comprehensive Guide

Introduction

Shareholders of Canadian corporations have several legitimate ways to extract funds, including salaries, dividends, and management fees. Another method is through shareholder loans, where funds are borrowed from the corporation. While this may seem straightforward, the Income Tax Act (ITA) has specific provisions to prevent abuse and ensure proper taxation of such transactions. This article explores the tax implications of shareholder loans, including potential income inclusions, exceptions, and practical strategies.

Income Inclusion and Key Exceptions

Under Section 15(2) of the ITA, shareholder loans are generally included in the borrower’s income unless specific conditions are met. This provision ensures that withdrawals disguised as loans are taxed to prevent shareholders from avoiding income tax on distributions.

1. Income Inclusion Rules

• Withdrawals by non-corporate shareholders or connected persons are included in the recipient’s income.
• If the loan remains unpaid beyond one year from the end of the corporation’s tax year, the loan amount and any applicable interest are added to the shareholder’s income for the year the loan was made.

2. Repayment Exception

Under Section 15(2.6), loans repaid within the allowable timeframe are not included in income:

• Example: If a corporation with a December 31 year-end lends funds on January 1, 2023, the shareholder has until December 31, 2024, to repay the loan to avoid income inclusion.

If the repayment condition is breached, any subsequent repayment may qualify for a deduction under Section 20(1)(j), offsetting the income inclusion in the year of repayment

3. Deemed Interest

Even if the repayment condition is met, shareholders may face a deemed interest inclusion if the corporation does not charge an interest rate at or above the prescribed rate (currently 1%, but subject to change).

Exceptions for Shareholder Employees

Section 15(2.4) outlines exemptions for loans to shareholder employees under certain conditions:

1. Loans to Non-Specified Employees:
   • Loans made to employees who are not specified employees (i.e., individuals holding 10% or more of the corporation’s shares) are exempt from income inclusion.
2. Loans for Housing Purchases:
   • Loans made to enable the purchase of a dwelling for the shareholder’s use are exempt.
3. Loans for Share Purchases:
   • Loans for acquiring unissued, fully paid shares in the corporation or a related corporation are excluded from income inclusion.
4. Loans for Motor Vehicle Acquisition:
   • Loans to purchase vehicles used for employment purposes are also exempt.

Conditions for Exemptions:

• The loan must be made qua employee (due to employment, not shareholding).
• Bona fide repayment arrangements must exist at the time the loan is made, specifying repayment terms and conditions.

Case Law: Mast v. The Queen (2013)

The Tax Court of Canada held that a $1 million interest-free loan to a sole shareholder did not qualify as an employee loan due to its excessive amount and lack of repayment terms, highlighting the importance of proper documentation.

CRA Audit Risks and Compliance Tips

Shareholder loans are frequently scrutinized by the CRA, particularly for:

1. Lack of Documentation:
   • Absence of formal loan agreements with clear repayment terms.
2. Loans to Specified Employees:
   • Transactions benefiting major shareholders may face additional scrutiny.
3. Improper Use of Exemptions:
   • Ensure loans are genuinely made qua employee to qualify for exemptions.

Income Splitting Strategies and Proposed Changes

Historically, shareholder loans were a tool for income splitting and tax deferral:

• Example: A family-owned corporation could lend funds to an adult child in university, allowing them to repay the loan when their income was higher, thus benefiting from lower tax rates.

Proposed Changes to Income Splitting

Recent amendments to Section 120.4 of the ITA (Tax on Split Income or TOSI rules) aim to eliminate these benefits:

• Loans to “specified individuals” (e.g., adult children of shareholders) will be taxed at the highest marginal rate, effectively negating any tax advantage.

Tax Planning Strategies

1. Repay Loans Within Two Corporate Year-Ends:
   • Avoid income inclusion by ensuring repayment within the allowable timeframe.
   • Use salary or dividend payments to offset outstanding loans.
2. Offer Housing or Vehicle Loans to Employees:
   • Incentivize employees with bona fide loans for housing or vehicles, leveraging ITA exemptions.
3. Ensure Proper Documentation:
   • Draft formal loan agreements with clear repayment schedules.
   • Include terms reflecting arm’s-length conditions.
4. Monitor Prescribed Interest Rates:
   • Charge interest at or above the prescribed rate to avoid deemed interest inclusions.
5. Consult Tax Professionals:
   • Work with Canadian tax experts to structure shareholder loans and ensure compliance.

FAQs

What happens if a shareholder loan is not repaid on time?

If the loan remains unpaid beyond the allowable timeframe, the full loan amount, plus any applicable interest, is included in the shareholder’s income for the year the loan was made.

Can shareholder loans be tax-free?

Loans can be tax-free if repaid on time or if they meet specific exemptions under Section 15(2.4) of the ITA (e.g., housing or vehicle loans).

How can shareholders minimize tax on loans?

Repay loans promptly, document all transactions, and consider paying salaries or dividends instead of taking loans.

Conclusion

While shareholder loans offer flexibility in accessing corporate funds, their tax treatment under the Income Tax Act is complex and requires careful planning. By understanding the rules, leveraging exemptions, and maintaining proper documentation, shareholders can mitigate tax risks and optimize financial outcomes. For tailored advice, consult with an experienced Canadian tax professional to navigate the intricacies of shareholder loan taxation effectively.

This article is written for educational purposes.

Should you have any inquiries, please do not hesitate to contact us at (905) 836-8755, via email at [email protected], or by visiting our website at www.taxpartners.ca.

Tax Partners has been operational since 1981 and is recognized as one of the leading tax and accounting firms in North America. Contact us today for a FREE initial consultation appointment.